Great Silence, The aka Il grande silenzio (1968)

The Great Silence is a bleak, cold spaghetti western with one of the most shocking, memorable endings ever in a western. The film isn't quite as put together or technically competent as its contemporary, Once Upon a Time in the West, but the subject material, setting, and ensuing climactic battle. The Great Silence revolves around corruption in a Utah town regarding the victimization of a group of Morman outcasts (who have bounties put on their heads). Frank Wolff plays a clumsy sheriff with good-intentions assigned to clean up Snowhill, UT, which is plagued by an infrastructure supporting scum like the bounty hunter Loco. Kinski's performance as Loco is quite excellent. Silence (Trintignant), an infamous mute gunslinger, arrives in town and begins a sort of investigation. The film's setting is unusual for a western: it's set in feet of snow with the weather playing heavily into the challenges of the film, from frozen guns and iced-over rivers to horses struggling to walk with the snow up to their bodies. And again, Ennio Morricone delivers a stellar score. The only major issues I had with the film were a slew of awkward moments that seemed script or director-related. These were not made any better by the absolutely terrible dub typical of 1960s Italian productions. Unfortunately, because both the English and Italian tracks were post-dubbed, I'm not confident the Italian dub would be much better.

8/10

Once Upon a Time in the West aka C'era una volta il West (1968)

Once Upon a Time in the West is a masterpiece spaghetti western from Sergio Leone, artfully deconstructing the Western genre and giving us something both clever and entertaining. A man and his family are murdered by a gang on the day of his new wife's arrival. Several men step in to help her discover why and prevent the inevitable confrontation with Frank (Fonda) and his men. Henry Fonda shockingly changes it up and plays the villain. Charles Bronson portrays a nameless cowboy who plays a harmonica and is haunted by his past. My favorite character was Cheyenne,  played by Jason Robards, as he brought a certain eloquent charisma to the role that the tougher characters lacked. Claudia Cardinale portrays the wife, complicated and sometimes difficult to sympathize with--I also don't think women were that hot back then. The film was often thought-provoking or just plain controversial, which makes it even better to mull over. Technically, the film is stunning, employing a surprisingly slow but perfectly executed pace and flowing cinematography. The sound design is striking, with all of the sounds of the Old West augmented in the mix (creating a kind of fantastic reality) which is aided by Ennio Morricone's brilliant score. Once Upon a Time in the West, along with The Wild Bunch, should be considered the crowning examples of an epic western.

10/10